A Tax on Trading is a Gift to Grifters
by Byrne Hobart
Categories: Uncategorized
A recent New York Times editorial recently made the case for a trading tax. Superficially, it’s tempting: if we have a way to make counterproductive gamblers pay up for their vices, why not use it? There are several problems with the proposal:
- As Christine Hurt at Conglomerate points out, this tax could hurt the traders who do the worst anyway: “We like to say that the “buy-and-hold” people come out on top, so then isn’t the tax regressive — taxing the silly speculators who don’t understand investing, just like lotteries are regressive taxes on poor people who are bad at math?”
- It’s a tax on liquidity, and we really need liquidity right now. One of the great




